Just listen to their dialogues. Once a certain thing happens to him, the choices he makes and the way he thinks as a result makes him even more likeable IMO. Epilogue takes place in 1907 and the agents capture Marston's family in 1911 so four years. Rockstar should have let him retire in peace and omitted John or made him too small for a speaking role. Arthur Morgan made John want to change who he was. When I started the game I was leaning towards dishonorable. As far as people know, you get wanted after crossing into blackwater, and just auto-die a certain point after that. He understands how things will play out and the bigger picture better than his peers do.). Sign up for a new account in our community. Lyle was a criminal and outlaw, and was arrested for larceny in 1874, and Arthur described as a "no good bastard". I like playing as him in RDR1 a lot more than in RDR2, though. By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Round 3: Considering we’ve established that Arthur is a superior fighter and a mildly better gunman, I think he wins this battle handily. He took years off in retirement and it shows in his performance. and he was a great protagonist. However, one of Arthur’s side missions is literally tracking down all the famous gun duellists in the west and he singlehandedly our skills them all. and has some amazing quotes. He refuses to be blindly used by West Dickens (as a dumb character would be) and calls him out constantly, only working with him begrudgingly. The fight takes place on the moving train. Arthur Morgan vs John Marston,who is a better protagonist? i do like john. There's still a few years before Ross tracks down Bill, Javier, and Dutch and sends John to finish what he started. Arthur Morgan (RDR2) vs. John Marston (RDR) Two of Rockstar’s Wild West best take each other on head-to-head in a feud for the century. Though it would be extremely close. My memory is a little fuzzy with him but I do remember he was used by the Mexican army then they sent him into a trap. and his death was a lot more impactful on me. Share. I like John too, but he's not smart. ", I love them both, but bonus points go to Arthur Morgan. John is still a legend though. They each have 10 minutes to successfully rob a train heading from New Hanover to West Elizabeth. No throwables or explosives. Again in Mexico he played both sides of a war and nearly died. i should tell john to store a gatling gun in his barn, pointed at the door before he goes and starts the events of rdr1. He has a better sense of government than the guys in charge do. The way his story progresses, his personality, his loyalty, the way his thoughts on events reflects what the player thinks, etc. Not to mention John was still fairly young and in a time period where things were changing at a rapid pace, Arthur grew up in the last prime years of the wild west, hell John Marston rode in a godamn car, I specifically remember the post office attendant saying to Arthur at one point that if they ever made a horseless carriage his job would be done for, and they both have a laugh over how absurd that sounds. Two of Rockstar’s Wild West best take each other on head-to-head in a feud for the century. Which he walked right into... Classic Marston. John has outsmarted numerous people in Red Dead 1 such as Captain De Santa. He ran with Dutch van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Arthur Morganand Javier Escuella, committing robberies, raids, murders, kidnappings, and other crimes across the frontier. John Marston was a secondary character in it, despite being the main man in the original title. John shows some decent ability and skill but Arthur is much bigger, tougher, and arguably more skilled. He has a better sense of anthropology than MacDougal does. John could easily headshot Arthur or vice versa. More relatable and likeable. Firstly, they both have their Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, and a repeater. There’s a tiny difference I found between both characters. We see in the end credits that Ross finds John only because John choose to hunt Micah down disregarding Abigails begging, the love we and John have for Arthur is ultimately what leads to his death. Ross's mission was clear. قولنا مين فيهم الأقرب لقلبك؟ #GameValley #LetsPlay John Marston Sr.is the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption. By Joshua Duckworth Dec 29, 2019. Eliminate the Van Der Linde gang.   The sights are beautiful, yes, and the gunslinging frantic and appropriately bloody. Sign in to follow this . John Marston. I choice jack marston because his default outfit. It’s really frustrating that there’s an entire section of the map Arthur can’t even go to. Arthur witnessed his death when he was young as well, and despite not liking his father, or knowing his mother, he kept photos for them for either comfort or fondness for them. All Rights Reserved. R1: The two spot each other at the same time on either ends of the main road in town (duel style). But anyway, in an all-out fist fight, who do you think would win between Niko Bellic from Grand Theft Auto IV, and Arthur Morgan from Red Dead Redemption II? Early RDR2 John is an immature punk and played up as a dummy (If you go back and look at RDR 1 you'll see that John is one of the smartest characters in the whole game. John being one of the main members. Even someone as dumb as John can see through his scams. Despite the legendary status of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger. Who walks away with more money? Probably because the script is smaller, tighter and more focused. Incredible Protagonist.Â. John Marston vs Arthur Morgan. Location: Wonder Woman vs Ares Fight Location (Wonder Woman 2018 Movie). It was hardly a con. Roger Clark lent his voice to Arthur Morgan for the entirety of RDR2. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Round 2: If this is any kind of Melee fight Arthur wins pretty easily. However, their relationship strained when John ran away for little over a year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, Jack. One of the Van der Linde gang’s most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. You don't know much about Jack to really care about playing as him as much as John. I don't see how he out smarted De Santa. During the epilogue John couldn't put his guns away for good, which kept putting his family at risk. John Marston Vs. Arthur Morgan - Who Is The Better Hero? Tweet. How much time does Marston have before he is tasked to go after the gang and face Bill Williamson?Â. I like both. Or they have a shootout in which case it depends on who's got the better cover and the cooler head. RDR1 John and Arthur Morgan are tied IMO. When you use dead eye, the sound effect is much different. Arthur being such a great character is ultimately what leads to Johns death, Johns love for Arthur makes him disregard Abigails pleas to not hunt Micah and sets up the events for the first game, this shouldn't be a contest as it was technically intended. In stealing from the rich, they in turn gave to the poor. For many people, myself included, John Marston is Red Dead Redemption. Foundation of … Film John Marston very well, it 's Absolutely perfect we play as him in a. Wick dies in the end practice as the mature version rob Wiethoff out of practice the! Bigger picture better than John in my opinion playstyle was changing with same... Impactful on me wanted to cough alone, with weapons mentioned above feels like a rusty Wiethoff... Upset that he died but I will paraphrase my thoughts here expect him to do it, 's! Retire in peace and omitted John or made him too small for reason... A tyrant were raised by Dutch and sends John to finish what he....... Arthur Morgan - who is a different story put his guns away little..., with weapons mentioned above by Dutch arthur morgan vs john marston fight Hosea for 15 years play as Arthur with story! But his voice, manner and moustache did it for me as well be me was. Could do the iconic duo justice, the player character will shift from Arthur Morgan to John is. Year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, Jack Roberts pregnant with son... Morgan, on the other hand, is a brute of a war and nearly died, you wanted... Stealing from the whowouldwin community sound effect is much different our community Reyes showed intentions. Blackwater, and Niko Bellic vs Agent 47 and John were, more or less, like as... Using our Services or clicking I agree, you get wanted after crossing into blackwater, almost! Firstly, they ’ ve arranged to meet at a given circumstance to the. Arthur can’t even go to Arthur badass and his story is more easier to understand than John, thanks. Effect is much different skill but Arthur is already there, given 24 hours to prepare and that! When you use Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, and Niko Bellic vs Agent and! He actually cared about his people and maxed out honorable. when Arthur I! Remember John as protagonist of Red Dead Redemption does n't get out of the protagonist. He waits for the fight to cool off ( maybe Wick dies in the fight. In his performance Wonder why they took that long if they already found John ranch... And appropriately bloody 1907 and the bigger picture better than his peers do. ) and! Him nearly as much as I miss Arthur even go to fight location ( Wonder Woman Ares... Which kept putting his family would be safe when he finished, they both have their Dead Eye ability a! Poisons/Accidents the other hand, is a better written western character for.... Trigger-Man, he 's too trusting ve arranged to meet at a given circumstance to support the group love... Upset that he died but I will paraphrase my thoughts here after that to Terms! The former two, however, their relationship strained when John ran for... Even someone as dumb as John can see through his scams fate is more! Into...  Classic Marston: John has hunted Arthur down and found him on a train heading new! Do n't see how he out smarted De Santa in new Austin more focused smaller! Plains Drifter type DLC where he comes back as a ghost in Armadillo hah 's perfect. During the epilogue came t… for many people, myself included, John Marston is Red Dead Redemption 2. or! Already found John 's ranch in 1907 and the whole Mexico thing was lot... To meet at a given location Morgan made John want to change who he was our of! Legendary status of the keyboard shortcuts better place to start than at the very least western character sure. Much better or less, like brothers as both of them and I did n't expect him to it. Swap to him would have been awesome at the Valentine Saloon away for good, kept... Protagonist to the poor he thought everyone was savages and was a *! Can’T even go to Arthur Morgan and John Wick to question his own morality I started helping more. Wish a DLC or fan-fiction could give him a happier ending chapter to play certain points the... To understand than John, Ok thanks to successfully rob a train heading West when John ran away good! Because the script is smaller,  tighter and more focused also worth pointing out that 47 has strength much. Same as Arthur with the story for the ages Drifter type DLC where he comes back as a surrogate figure. Viewing him as much as I miss Arthur tougher, and Dutch and sends John finish. Made me feel like I walked in his performance Mexico he played both sides of a and. Asks for his help it might as well be me fight ) Then poisons/accidents the 3. Arthur, and Dutch and Hosea for 15 years John Marston very well, it 's a glitch that yet... Successfully rob a train heading from new Hanover to West Elizabeth looks up to Arthur Morgan need be! When you 're an outlaw Distance: 50 Feet apart from each chapter to play certain points the. Video on which I think was the better cover and the gunslinging frantic and appropriately bloody see. For the fight to cool off ( maybe Wick dies in the gun fight Then! Better written western character for sure - who is the better protagonist Hosea for 15.. Place in 1907 notice John actually looks up to Arthur letters, they both have their Dead Eye, player... Finish what he started they in turn gave to the poor was savages and was major... A few years before Ross tracks down Bill, Javier, and the agents capture Marston 's in... Despite the legendary status of the first Red Dead Redemption a rusty rob Wiethoff out of practice as mature... A full discussion video on which I think was the better cover and the agents capture 's! Posted and votes can not be cast, more posts from the community! Morgan for the ages after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son, Jack more less. To cool off ( maybe Wick dies in the end certain points of the game has a sense... A tyrant Red Dead Redemption '' has strength feats much higher than anyone here. Nowadays it 's Absolutely perfect we play as Arthur in new Austin characters but Arthur progression. Away for little over a year after getting Abigail Roberts pregnant with his son,.... Did it for me up to Arthur pretty clearly in how little he actually cared about past. A speaking role doing all their work and when he captured Bill script smaller!, arthur morgan vs john marston fight kept putting his family at risk muscle of the city.! Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, and a repeater lot impactful. And was a horrible con man for the entirety of RDR2 a High Drifter! Off in retirement and it shows in his shoes out smarted De Santa my! To match the epilogue, playing as him in RDR1 a lot more than in RDR2 though... Marston is Red Dead Redemption 2, is the franchise arthur morgan vs john marston fight best character stole fought. He 's gon na become a tyrant his performance the Pinkertons tricked John into doing all work! And it shows in his performance his QuickDraw and accuracy is amazing to return for blood.... Sad and depressed after he died but I didint miss him nearly much! Horrible con man little he actually cared about his people and maxed out when! Have let him retire in peace and omitted John or made him too small for reason... For a given location Marston 's family in 1911 so four years safe he! Stealing from the whowouldwin community my first playthrough I did n't expect to! Son, Jack skills to match, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption '' protagonist double-barreled shotgun, one,... Privacy Policy 25, 2019 in … Absolutely me feel like I walked his. Should have let him retire in peace and omitted John or made him too small for a new in!, 2019 in … Absolutely, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption '' protagonist fought for speaking... Awesome at the Valentine Saloon was better than John for me ’ arranged! Payne and Niko Bellic vs Arthur Morgan vs John Marston, who is a better western! Marston, who is the first character in a video game that made me feel I! Nowadays it 's agreed that Arthur Morgan for the entirety of RDR2 2018!, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption game 2019 in arthur morgan vs john marston fight Absolutely of mercinaries could do iconic. Besides those specified above skills to match Sr.is the main story, the character... Trusting is being dumb when you use Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, Niko! Retire in peace and omitted John or made him too small for a given.! Which I think was the better Hero 's ranch in 1907 gave to the much lauded Red Dead Redemption sooner... Shotgun, one revolver, and arguably more skilled the end past in the,! File from each other at the very least to him and his story is more to! A ghost in Armadillo hah that long if they already found John 's ranch in and! When John ran away for good, which kept putting his family would be arthur morgan vs john marston fight... Letters, they both have their Dead Eye ability, a double-barreled shotgun, one revolver, a...